Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Doug Wilson on being a “Food Libertarian”

Doug Wilson is a “Food Libertarian”. He explains why here.

He concedes some role for government to play referee. He assesses that government should make food producers liable for the harm they do, and this is right after he says that consumers ought to take their own risks.

I believe he is separating two different kinds of risk that don’t need to be separated. One is risk in food preparation and the other is risk in the food itself. He seems to think that risk in food preparation requires some sort of tort law, but for risks in the food itself like unpasteurized milk, “people know what they’re getting”. Actually, in either case they don’t know what they’re getting. Maybe unpasteurized milk will get you sick and maybe a particular restaurant will get you sick. Either way risks are being taken and risk reductions will cost the consumer whether it is from legislation or market demand.

I commented,

“Very good thinking, but I think you missed something.

I don't see any reason for government to play the referee. If the risk is already internalized in the price of the meal, then there is no reason to make the producer liable for damages. By adding in the price of liability to the price of risk, your making food too safe. You're in effect making consumers pay twice the premium for risk reductions than they demand.

It is unlike tort law because the damages are agreed to. The person who got sick agreed to getting sick because they agreed to bare the risk of getting sick. It has already been paid for. The price is right. With, say, pollution the externalized costs are on parties which did not consent.

It seems to me that if there is a market failure it is the other way around. Consumers respond irrationally when a few people dying from a gordita or there is a "scare" of some kind. Psychologists call it an availability heuristic. People overrate the odds of events they hear about frequently. Market forces respond to this with excessive safety standards. Producers are scared to death that they'll be the subject of the big news disaster story, even if the victims of such a story won the negative lottery.

So we're both food libertarians. You might like Tyler Cowen's book, An Economist gets Lunch.”

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Amia Srinivasan of New York Times Questions for Free Market Ethics

I came across this article from the New York Times which calls the moral intuitions of free market ethicists into question. To be honest, this is the kind of fake intellectualism that New York Times readers go for but wouldn’t pass an ideological turing test by a long-shot.

These are the four free market moral intuitions she calls into question followed by my brief responses.

1. “Is any exchange between two people in the absence of direct physical compulsion by one party against the other (or the threat thereof) necessarily free?”

It doesn’t matter what you call it. Call it free or don’t. Just to be nice lets call it not free. What happens when we “free” a woman from having to prostitute herself or sell her organs by prohibiting the only way she can feed herself? She starves. She’s choosing her only alternative to starvation and prohibiting it starves her. Moral intuitions change when we come to a better understanding of outcomes.

There is a very real difference between coercion and -- let's call them extreme vulnerability examples. The option that one is being coerced into is less than their best option, or else coercion isn’t needed. On the other hand, in the extreme vulnerability examples they’re choosing the best option available, even if it is not very good. Prohibiting the best option available opens up weaker alternatives, while prohibiting coercion opens up stronger alternatives.

So yes, I would call it free, it is morally permissible, and even desirable to allow people to sell their organs or prostitute themselves if they’re extremely vulnerable. Preventing poor people and sick people trade money for organs keep the poor poor and the sick sick.

2. "Is any free (not physically compelled) exchange morally permissible?”

The answer to this is actually no. Minimally, I don’t think it is morally permissible to sell drugs to a drug addict. I do find it morally permissible to offer a worker $1 a year to work on a farm you inherited. Why would he take $1 if it weren’t the best of his available alternatives? Would it be better for me not to give him the job if his alternatives are starvation, prostitution, or a $.99 a day job? Nobody else offers him better alternatives, so the fact that I pay him a dollar cannot come packaged with the moral responsibility to pay him more than a dollar.

The question at hand breaks through at least one libertarian barrier. Some exchanges are not morally permissible. However, in order to justify government force one has to also show that 1) violence is an appropriate way to respond to this moral impermissibility (by appropriate I mean both morally permissible and constructive) And 2) that realistic government uses its power in such cases without corresponding uses in cases where violence is not permissible.

I think the author falls into the trap of assuming that if the non-government sector is imperfect, then that justifies the use of the government sector. That morally impermissible things can happen, and probably will happen under market conditions does not justify the permissibility of the government sector.

By the way, general economic growth ensures that these grim situations don’t happen. The standard of living could not be increased from the level of year 1800 poor to the level of the poor of today through legislation. The standard of living for the poor of today is drastically higher, and there is no plausible argument for why  legislation directed at distribution were the cause.

3. Do people deserve all they are able, and only what they are able, to get through free exchange?

No. But I anticipate that I do a lot less asserting off the top of my head what CEOs, teachers, and McDonalds workers “deserve”. I have no mechanism to identify how deserved each person’s lot is. I do have efficiency to go off of though, and I find it unlikely that boards of directors are paying more than what is efficient for CEOs.

The author explains that if the rich keep giving their money to their kids, then money stays in the hands of the few. This is fuel for the “they don’t deserve it” emotions. The fallacy is in what economists call the money illusion. People incorrectly think of money in nominal, rather than real, terms. So the rich all get together at the Republican party meeting and chant, “buahahaha, now we have all the green pieces of paper and all the poor people get stuck with those lousy goods and services.” People are giving them little green pieces of paper because they’re providing wealth, and when one of them creates ways to divert those little green pieces of paper in their direction, the value of those little green pieces of paper goes up.

What about inheritance? Well when a rich person gives their money to a poor person, that isn’t morally repugnant. That doesn’t change if the poor person happens to be their offspring. The children of the wealthy didn’t do anything to earn their inheritance, but neither did the pauper who happened upon a large sum of money but when people hear about that they think it’s just dandy. Besides that, parents tend to be more productive when they can pass on their wealth to their children, and their children tend to inherit the intelligence and conscientiousness that helps put that money to good use anyway.

People’s capacity to produce wealth differs, but the extent that it is luck is a lottery is exaggerated. It is largely an extent of choices. My observation of my co-workers is that they either chronically made bad choices, did not value money very much because not everyone is racing to the same get rich finish line, or they were young and went off to better things. There were few who were there as a result of something other than decisions. Most people think they’re being good people by never questioning the poor’s presumptive status as victims, but are they being intellectually honest? I would prefer they turn their attention to people who are actually poor or can’t help themselves. That means people from poor countries, the homeless, the disabled, and children. That excludes McDonald’s workers and their equivalents.

Reductions in welfare cannot be a contributor to median income stagnation. Welfare is targeted at the lowest economic bracket, and unless you think it is boosting them up to $50,000 a year, welfare does not change median income.

The magnitude of funds which the lottery (economy) is capable of dishing out is a function of production, which is a function of capital, which is a function of profit.

The idea that government would be able to anticipate that consumers would one day value Edgar Allen Poe’s work treats government like it is omniscient. Again, it isn’t market versus perfection. It is market versus government relative to perfection.

4. Are people under no obligation to do anything they don’t freely want to do or freely commit themselves to doing?

No. But no libertarians I’ve ever met believes that. No libertarians I have ever heard of believe that all free choices are moral. Is the author thinking of libertines?

People still have moral obligations if they don’t have government. Does the author think that if libertarianism doesn’t cleanse the world of immorality then it is false? The entire critique if filled with that assumption.



Monday, November 11, 2013

Bystander Apathy does not prove a Society is Apathetic

In October 2011, a two-year-old girl, Wang Yue, was hit by a small, white van in the city of Foshan, China, then run over by a large truck when she was not moved by bystanders. A total of 18 people ignored her, some going so far as to walk around the blood. The girl was left for 7 minutes before a recycler, Chen Xianmei, picked up the toddler and called for help. The child died eight days later.

This is just one of several stories that exemplify what is called bystander empathy. Some use it to depict the world of today as one which totally lacks compassion. The apathy that people have toward their fellow man is astoundingly low, resulting in a sick cruel world that we see in examples such as this. But is that how we should really interpret such events?

Here’s the thing. This story and other examples of bystander apathy make such great shock and awe stories because it isn’t what we expect in the real world. I don’t mean the real world like the ideal world in our heads kind of way. I mean the real world like everything we observe in our daily life kind of way. Bystander apathy completely contradicts what we realistically expect from other human beings. The story of Wang Yue is bizarre. I’m not saying it isn’t true, but it is so spectacular because it is the outlier to the typical rule that people generally are compassionate. That’s why it is called a psychological phenomenon.

If the bystander apathy really represented the world in general then it wouldn’t be news.

This means that we should not be using such stories to prove the point that the world is without compassion.

 

 

Saturday, November 9, 2013

Blinks

 

Monday, November 4, 2013

The United States has a Higher Rate of Poverty, but Average Rate of Low Standard of Living

The relative poverty threshold differs from country to country because of the way poverty is defined. Many countries do not calculate the poverty rate, and other countries define it in different ways. Experts alleviate this problem by defining it as the number of people beneath a percentage of that country’s median income. The problem with this is that many make the mistake of comparing the poverty rate between countries as if that is saying something about the differences in the real standard of living for the poor. What has to be done in order to compare the absolute standard of living of those in poverty in different countries is use the same country’s definition of poverty.

A little secret is that the United States has a very high median income compared to most developed countries. That means that when they carve the poverty line out of that median income, it is setting a higher bar. What happens when we keep that bar constant and see how other countries compare the the United State’s poverty threshold?

anigif_enhanced-buzz-7083-1375375996-46

Coyote Blog points out a study which compares apples to apples in the definition of poverty between country. Tim Worstall takes credit for pointing it out in the comments. The study is here, and it is intended to shed negative light on the United State’s poverty problem compared to other countries. But it does so by defining poverty the same way many other studies do it – by defining it is 50% of that country’s median income.

“A majority of cross-national studies define the poverty threshold as one-half
of national median income, and we will follow that convention in most of this
paper.”

When other developed countries are compared to the United States using the same poverty threshold (50% of U.S. Median income, the United States does alright – not spectacular, not horrendous – but okay. Juxtapose that to comparisons where the definition of poverty varies country by country, and United States hits dead last.

anigif_enhanced-buzz-23571-1363805457-13

 

Its okay to make the case that income relative to your peers matters. But it needs to be made clear what the data is saying and is not saying. It is not saying that there are more poor people in America living below a particular standard of living than in other developed countries. But that is the idea that most people derive from these kinds of international comparisons. And that is the idea that incites all kinds of aghast feelings and social justice revolts. What the data is saying is that there are at or near the same percentage of the American population living beneath a particular standard of living as other countries, but the people above it are doing better in America than in other countries… And if one wants to point out that that is a bad thing because there is additional utility to be derived from equality, then be my guest. But make that distinction because the typical viewer won’t.

 

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Christian Morality that Changes with Culture

I recently heard some Christians point out that many of the moral laws of the old testament are actually variables dependent on cultural standards. They’re not fixed like moral principles. Some of these include what we eat, what we wear, and what we say. They pointed out that many of the restrictions only make sense during a particular time and particular place. For example Paul wrote to the Corinthians that a woman should not cut her hair (1 Corinthians 11:6). There are various dietary commands found in Leviticus (Leviticus 19:19). And there are warnings against calling your brother “raca” (Matthew 5:22). These kinds of rules change as cultural norms change since they are in fact applications of more basic moral principles (like concern yourself with your health, dress appropriately, and don’t use language abusively). What it means to be healthy changes as human knowledge of nutrition and the body develops. What it means to dress appropriately changes depending on cultural standards. And what it means to not use abusive language changes as linguistic expressions change and between groups of people.

There are plenty of versus that articulate the more basic principle that these commands attempt to apply. Ephesians 4:29 says to use language that is “good for building up” and “as fits the occasion”. Corinthians 6:20 says to honor God with our bodies. Timothy 2:9 says to dress modestly. These are the articulation of some of the more basic principles being applied in the other versus.

What I found interesting is how easily it was to translate these scriptures into the modern evangelical culture, but how difficult it was to translate it out of the modern evangelical culture. If I’m eating dinner with people from the modern evangelical culture, and I say, “goddamn this lasagna is amazing”, they might be horrified. But if I’m eating dinner with people next door, and I say, “goddamn this lasagna is amazing”, someone might respond, “well let me give you the recipe!” What ends up being appropriate is a variable dependent on the time and place it is being said. The moral principle is independent of culture, but how it is applied is going to depend very much on it. Popular Christianity has trouble seeing the appropriateness of the alternative situation.

We can easily come up with some other examples. Phrases like, “you son of a bitch” is not abusive if my buddy just took a bite out of my sandwich, while quite abusive if he just stole my girlfriend. The meaning of the phrase changed from un-abusive to abusive between those two situations because only in the latter situation am I actually tearing him down. In the former we are just having fun.

My wife can let her hair down in public because in this day-and-age, letting your hair down does not signal to others that she’s a prostitute. Christian culture has moved with mainstream from the taboo of a woman showing her ankles. Popular Christianity gets that because we’re translating into their current culture. However, places where women stride topless on beaches Christians is still oftentimes seen as wrong by many Christians. The length a skirt can be before it communicates something risqué is no doubt shorter in mainstream culture than it is in evangelical culture.

 

Saturday, November 2, 2013

A Facebook Summary of the Christian View of Government Welfare

On Steve Jeffrey’s Facebook wall, I found an opportunity to overview what I think the Christian view of government welfare ought to be. My brief overview of the long discussion confirmed a lot of the usual objections to libertarian Christianity – the idea that libertarian’s don’t believe in charity – the idea that government is the reason why are children aren’t getting their limbs blown off in factories, and we don’t all die from being sold lethal sandwiches – the idea that poor people are still poor no matter how rich they are (because it is a term defined relative to others). So I wrote a response which ended up being about as brief a sketch I could make of moral and economic arguments against government welfare.

So here we go:

I've never ever met a libertarian who didn't believe in private charity. Did Jesus ever take money by threat of coercion in order to help others? That is what governments do. Did Jesus ever carve out a moral exception for lawmakers and law enforcers? Never read it. Moral law is universal, and it doesn't concern itself with the labels people have given other people like "government".

Examples from the past of how hard it used to be are not relevant. General economic growth matters for these types of things. Risk reductions have a price. Improvements in working conditions have a price. Children moving from being hard laborers to students has a price. It isn't like all the bad parents happen to live in Bangladesh. General economic growth doesn't just take the form of more and cheaper stuff, it also takes the form of compensating differentials.

Defining "poor" relative to the wealth of a country is a mistake. Jesus helped poor people and people who couldn't help themselves, we should help poor people and people who can't help themselves. But that means actual poor people. Not people like me who live with under $15,000 a year. Actual poor people live with a fraction of that. Homeless people actually need help. People in third world countries actually need help. Children and the disabled actually can't help themselves. The general population of low income earners in a rich country, live well and can help themselves.

The fact that somebody else sacrificed in order for me to consume more is very real with private charity. I don't want to take advantage of someone who has personally sacrificed in order to help me. When the check comes in from some general faceless "tax payer" yes there is an attitude of entitlement and the reality that I'm living off of someone else is not real.

The foundational moral argument in the first paragraph points out that minimally we need a good reason before we coerce people. “I’m from the IRS” or “I’m a Senator”, are not good reasons. “He’s poorer than you” or “it’s efficient” are also not good answers. Good answers might include “he’s about to die” or “you’re acting violently”. Some say that Jesus didn’t even allow for that by calling for radical pacifism in Matthew 5:38-39. Either way, government activity is radically reduced by calling for law enforcers and law makers to abide by the universal moral law that we expect everyone else to adhere to.